The Culture of Disposability: Examining the "Chhoti Si Bhool" Narrative in Pakistan

As a clinical psychologist, one cannot overlook the devastating emotional and psychological impact of patriarchal narratives deeply rooted in Pakistani society. The phrase "chhoti si bhool" (a small mistake) is emblematic of this injustice, trivializing women's pain and framing their struggles as mere lapses of judgment. This narrative, designed to shame and silence, underscores the disposability of women’s autonomy, dignity, and worth in a culture that often prioritizes male dominance over female well-being.

The Burden of "Chhoti Si Bhool"

In Pakistan, women are frequently held to impossible moral standards. A consensual relationship, a premarital pregnancy, or even being a victim of harassment is labeled as a "mistake" for which women are solely accountable. The phrase "chhoti si bhool" is often weaponized to minimize the actions of men while amplifying the consequences for women. This doublespeak allows men to escape accountability while leaving women to bear the weight of societal judgment and familial shame.

Men exploit women under the guise of relaxation, intimacy, or companionship, only to discard them when convenient. Whether the man identifies as a feminist or not, he is rarely a protector of a woman’s dignity unless committed through marriage. The harsh truth remains: men wield privilege, and in doing so, often reduce women to mere stepping stones in their journey toward self-gratification.

The Psychological Cost of Disposability

The "chhoti si bhool" narrative creates a toxic environment that devastates women’s mental health. It fosters:

1. Gaslighting and Victim-Blaming: Women are made to feel that any violation of their dignity is their fault. The psychological toll of being blamed for one’s trauma can lead to deep-seated anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).

2. Isolation and Silence: Fear of judgment discourages women from seeking support or speaking out. They are trapped in a cycle of shame and secrecy, further compounding their mental distress.

3. Erosion of Agency: Women’s choices are systematically invalidated. Their autonomy is dismissed as insignificant, reducing their existence to a function of male approval and societal expectations.

Patriarchy’s Perpetual Grip

Patriarchy thrives on the objectification of women, viewing them as vessels for male satisfaction rather than autonomous beings. Men, by default, are socialized to assert control over women’s lives, policing their behavior and punishing perceived transgressions. The "chhoti si bhool" narrative serves as a reminder of this dominance, reinforcing the belief that men are entitled to make mistakes while women must live flawlessly or face dire consequences.

Even self-proclaimed feminists, while vocal in theory, often fail to translate their beliefs into action that protects women in practice. Without structural and personal commitment, they too fall into the patterns of exploitation and abandonment, leaving women vulnerable to systemic harm.

The Emotional Weight of Being a Woman in Pakistan

Women in Pakistan are more than victims of systemic injustice—they are survivors navigating a hostile environment where their dignity is constantly under siege. From being called "mistakes" to being used and discarded, their emotional and psychological scars are the silent testament to a culture that devalues their humanity.

To exist as a woman in this society is to walk a tightrope: to carry the burden of family honor, to endure objectification and exploitation, and to find self-worth in a world determined to strip it away. Women are not inherently "wo-men" to stop men; they are individuals deserving of respect and autonomy. It is when men refuse to recognize this humanity that they embody the very bastards they decry.

Moving Toward Change

Addressing the "chhoti si bhool" narrative requires dismantling patriarchal systems that perpetuate these injustices. It is time to:

1. Hold Men Accountable: Recognize and address the role men play in perpetuating these harmful dynamics. Accountability must replace excuses and dismissal.

2. Empower Women: Create safe spaces where women can speak openly, seek justice, and regain control over their narratives.

3. Challenge Cultural Norms: Educate communities about the harm of gender-based stereotypes and double standards.

Until society values women as whole individuals rather than disposable entities, the wounds inflicted by the "chhoti si bhool" narrative will remain a haunting legacy of oppression. Women in Pakistan deserve a future where their worth is not defined by men’s mistakes or society’s skewed morality but by their own strength and resilience.

Summary

The "chhoti si bhool" (a small mistake) narrative in Pakistan trivializes women's struggles and perpetuates a culture of disposability, where their autonomy and dignity are dismissed. This phrase is used to shame and blame women for perceived transgressions, such as relationships, harassment, or assault, while absolving men of accountability. This patriarchal mindset objectifies women, reduces their existence to serving male interests, and places the burden of family honor and societal expectations solely on their shoulders. The psychological toll is immense, leading to anxiety, depression, PTSD, and isolation. Men, even self-proclaimed feminists, often exploit women without offering protection or support, reinforcing systemic inequality. To challenge this harmful narrative, society must hold men accountable, empower women to reclaim their agency, and dismantle gender-based stereotypes. Women deserve respect and autonomy, free from the cultural and emotional scars inflicted by the "chhoti si bhool" narrative.

Thank You for reading 🙏 😊