The Psychology Behind "Are You Chinese?" - Why We Otherize Cultural Celebrations

Today is Qixi Festival, often called Chinese Valentine's Day. In the spirit of connection, I decided to spread some joy. I sent "Happy Chinese Valentine's Day!" messages to about 300 people online and said it to 25 in person.


The response was overwhelmingly positive, but it was followed by a single, predictable question from 99% of them:


"Are you Chinese?"


This struck me. On February 14th, when I wish people a "Happy Valentine's Day," no one ever asks, "Are you Italian?" or "Are you American?" despite the holiday's European origins. The greeting is accepted at face value.


So why does a cultural celebration from Asia trigger an immediate identity check? As a psychologist, I see this not as mere curiosity, but a window into powerful underlying cognitive processes. It’s a perfect example of how we "otherize" cultures different from our own and create unconscious mental gatekeeping.


Our brains are wired to create categories. It’s a mental shortcut (a heuristic) that helps us navigate a complex world. However, these shortcuts often lead to biases.


1. The Out-Group Homogeneity Bias

This is a classic social psychology concept. We tend to view members of our own group (the "in-group") as diverse individuals ("I celebrate Valentine's Day, but so do my friends, my family, and we all do it differently"). However, we perceive members of other groups (the "out-group") as more similar to each other ("*They* celebrate Chinese holidays").


When I, someone who doesn't "look" like I belong to that out-group, participate in their custom, it creates a cognitive dissonance. The brain's quickest way to resolve it is to assume I must, in fact, be part of that group—hence, "Are you Chinese?"


2. Cultural Schemas and Scripts

We have mental frameworks, or "schemas," for how things work. Our schema for "Western Valentine's Day" is broad and inclusive: flowers, chocolates, cards, for anyone, anywhere. For many, their schema for "Chinese Valentine's Day" is narrow and tied exclusively to Chinese identity. My greeting didn't fit their script, so their mind sought to update it by verifying my identity.


3. The Subtle Art of Otherizing

Otherizing is the process of viewing or treating a person or group of people as intrinsically different from and alien to oneself. By immediately asking about my heritage, the focus shifts from the *celebration itself* (a universal concept of love) to *my right to participate*. It subconsciously frames the holiday as "theirs," not "ours" or everyone's.


This is why the comparison to American Valentine's Day is so crucial. The West has often globalized its culture, making it the "default." Non-Western cultures, despite their vast global populations, are often still seen as "niche" or "foreign" by those unfamiliar with them.


Beyond Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh: A Universal Human Tendency

In your prompt, you mentioned these three countries specifically. It's important to note that this isn't a flaw unique to any one region. This is a **universal human psychological response**.


I would have received the same question from people in many Western, Latin American, or African countries if they were unfamiliar with the festival. We all have blind spots. The goal isn't to assign blame, but to build awareness. The question itself isn't inherently bad—it's a potential starting point for curiosity. The issue is the assumption behind it.


From Gatekeeping to Cultural Curiosity: A Healthier Mindset

So, how do we move from a mindset of "otherizing" to one of genuine cultural appreciation? It starts with rewiring our initial reactions.


Instead of asking "Are you Chinese?", try asking:

"Oh, that's interesting! What does that day celebrate?"

"How is that day typically observed?"

"I'm not familiar with that, could you tell me more about it?"


These questions are bridges. They acknowledge your own knowledge gap without making assumptions about the other person's identity. They open a dialogue instead of closing a door.


Culture is not a fence designed to keep people out. It is a flowing river of stories, traditions, and human experiences that everyone can learn from and appreciate.


My experiment on Qixi Festival wasn't just about spreading good wishes. It was a small social test that revealed a profound truth about our mental categorizations. The next time someone shares a piece of their culture with you, see it as an invitation to learn, not a puzzle to be solved by figuring out their "right" to share it.


Let's work on expanding our schemas, challenging our biases, and embracing the beautiful, diverse ways humanity expresses universal values like love.

Popular posts from this blog

Importance of emotional intelligence and self-reflection in social media research

Social media, although an imaginary realm in many ways, is deeply rooted in our real-world experiences. Consider a study where 20 participants are observed: 10 playing cricket live on a field, and 10 engaging in the same activity through a 3D virtual reality device from their beds. Interestingly, the MRI or fMRI results from both groups would likely show similar brain activity, as for the brain, both experiences are equally real. Our brain processes all experiences—real or imagined—as if they are happening in the present moment. Whether we are living life authentically or imagining it behind a screen, we are still engaging with our surroundings in a meaningful way. In this sense, we are our imaginations, and we are also our real selves. Research on social media presents its own set of challenges. People often base their judgments and assumptions on what has been said or done by others at a specific time. In this context, it’s easy for individuals to taunt, criticize, or even try to und...
Read more

Understanding Social Constraints: A Psychological Perspective on Conformity and Individuality

Human beings are inherently social creatures, driven by an innate desire for connection, validation, and belonging. However, the complexity of societal norms and cultural expectations often creates a clash between individuality and conformity. This conflict is particularly pronounced when an individual's thoughts, feelings, or behaviors deviate from societal expectations. Such experiences can lead to emotional distress, social ostracism, or even trauma, revealing the intricate interplay between psychology and cultural dynamics. The Burden of Societal Norms Psychologists often refer to the phenomenon of adapting to societal expectations as normative social influence. This refers to the pressure to conform to the beliefs, values, and behaviors that are widely accepted within a specific cultural or social group. While conformity can foster cohesion, it often stifles individuality, particularly in societies with rigid patriarchal structures or deeply ingrained traditions. For example, ...
Read more

The Unspoken Realities of Adulthood: A Psychological Perspective

Adulthood is not just about age—it is about understanding humans. It is the stage where you finally see through the masks people wear, where you realize that kindness is not just a virtue but a necessity. Every human craves validation, seeks superiority, and wants to feel important. Carl Jung put it aptly—life is a constant struggle for priority. Have you ever noticed how even the simplest debates turn into battles of ego? The winner walks away feeling triumphant as if they have won a grand prize, while the loser carries an unspoken wound. When I understood this, I stopped debating. I learned to simply say, "Yes," "You're right," "Okay fine," and move on. Because why waste energy explaining something to someone who lacks the capacity or willingness to understand? Knowledge is not for display—it is for personal growth. The Faces People Wear People are double-faced. It is not pessimism; it is reality. A person who is a friend to everyone is a friend ...
Read more